Exotic NFL Prop Bets: Unconventional Markets to Target for Big Payouts

Introduction: Unlocking Value in Exotic Prop Bets

While most bettors stick to traditional bets like point spreads and totals, there’s a world of exciting opportunities in exotic prop bets. These bets venture beyond the game’s final score, offering unique markets and often larger payouts. Think of wagers on things like the first scoring play, the jersey number of the first touchdown scorer, or even the coin toss. These markets might seem whimsical, but with the right strategy, they can be highly profitable.

What Are Exotic NFL Prop Bets?

Exotic props are bets on outcomes that are generally unrelated to the final game score. They are popular during big events like the Super Bowl but are also offered during regular season games. Examples include:

  • First Player to Score a Touchdown: This is a fun but high-risk market where you bet on which player will reach the end zone first.
  • Jersey Number Props: Bettors can wager whether the first player to score a touchdown wears a number over or under a certain threshold (e.g., over 19.5)​(
    Odds Shark
    )​(
    BetMGM
    ).
  • Coin Toss and Gatorade Color: More lighthearted bets include wagering on whether the opening coin toss will be heads or tails or what color Gatorade will be dumped on the winning coach.

Why Bet on Exotic Props?

Exotic props often have higher odds due to their unpredictability, meaning the potential for larger payouts. This type of betting is ideal for bettors looking for variety or high-risk, high-reward opportunities.

Top Strategies for Exotic NFL Prop Bets:

  1. Stick to Patterns: Look for repeated trends or past performances. For example, teams that rely heavily on specific players in the red zone may make it easier to predict first touchdown scorers.
  2. Analyze Game Context: Exotic bets like total field goals or defensive scores can be swayed by weather, coaching tendencies, or the style of play. A windy day might lead to fewer successful field goals but more punt returns​(
    BetMGM
    )​(
    Odds Shark
    ).
  3. Research Unique Markets: Some exotic markets, like whether the game will go into overtime or whether there will be a safety, can offer value for bettors who dig deep into team and situational statistics​(
    Odds Shark
    ).

Final Thoughts:

Exotic prop bets add a layer of excitement to NFL betting, with potential for big payouts. By using informed strategies, such as analyzing trends and focusing on player roles, bettors can unlock significant value in these unconventional markets.


More in

Explore how to capitalize on defensive prop bets like sacks, interceptions, and turnovers. This guide provides key insights into reading matchups, studying offensive weaknesses, and leveraging advanced defensive metrics for smarter bets.

NFL player prop bets focus on individual performance, offering exciting opportunities beyond just team wins and losses. This guide explores strategies to maximize your success, including game flow analysis, advanced metrics, and leveraging injury reports.

Betting on defensive and special teams props is a unique way to profit from NFL games. Learn how to bet on defensive plays like sacks, interceptions, and forced fumbles, and find value in special teams moments like blocked kicks and punts.